Donate Shop Register


Unilateral Palestinian Demand for Recognition of Statehood Violates Past Agreements

UNILATERAL PALESTINIAN DEMAND FOR RECOGNITION OF STATEHOOD VIOLATES PAST AGREEMENTS, DELIVERS BLOW TO HOPES FOR PEACE

StandWithUs Statement:

In the fall of 2010, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas refused to resume direct peace negotiations with Israel. Instead, he is actively trying to abandon negotiations altogether. He has asked the international community to immediately recognize an independent Palestinian state with borders on the pre-1967 armistice lines.  This January, he asked the UN Security Council to condemn all Israeli building in settlements.  It is not clear when or if the resolution will be submitted to a vote.[1]

A handful of South American countries, including Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, Bolivia, and Ecuador, complied and recognized a Palestinian state in December.[2]Other states may follow their lead. In stark contrast, the EU rejected the Palestinian request, declaring that it would recognize a Palestinian state only “when appropriate” and would not condone any changes to “the pre-1967 borders...other than those agreed by the parties” through “negotiations.” [3] U.S. officials and Congress denounced the Palestinian effort in even stronger terms. In a unanimously approved resolution, the U.S. House of Representatives underscored that "true and lasting peace between Israel and the Palestinians can only be achieved through direct negotiations between the parties” and urged other nations to reject the Palestinians’ appeal. [4]    U.S. officials also oppose the Palestinian appeal to the UN Security Council.  "We're working to keep the focus where we think it needs to be [direct negotiations] and that is not in New York," U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said on January 19th.[5]

While Israelis and many Palestinians long for a peaceful, two-state solution, this latest effort by Palestinian leaders is a crushing blow to hopes for peace and should be firmly rejected.

     Unilateral Palestinian action directly violates past PLO-Israel agreements. After painstaking diplomatic efforts, Israel and the PLO signed the Oslo Accords in 1993 and in 1995, both times under U.S. supervision. The Accords specifically called for a negotiated resolution to the permanent status of the West Bank, including the issues of borders, Jerusalem, and Palestinian statehood. The Accords explicitly forbid either side from taking unilateral steps that would prejudge the final status of the disputed territory. Yet, Mahmoud Abbas, president of the Palestinian Authority (PA) and chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), is now trying to take unilateral steps.

Neither Israel nor the PA has ever renounced their commitment to these agreements. If the PA now violates them, the whole edifice of peacemaking will be undermined, including the legitimacy of the PA that was established through the Accords.

·      Recognizing a state on the pre-1967 lines directly violates UN Security Council Resolutions 242 and 338. Both resolutions call for negotiated land-for-peace agreements that will lead to “secure and recognized boundaries.” The pre-1967 line separating Israel and the West Bank was an armistice line delineated at the conclusion of the Arab states’ war to destroy Israel in 1948. It was never recognized as an international border, and the UN Resolutions did not regard it as a secure border for Israel. The PA and nations that comply with the PA unilateral declaration of statehood on the pre-1967 line are in defiance of the UN resolutions.

·      Unilateral Palestinian action does not address the major obstacle to peace: terrorism. Hamas, which remains in an active state of war against Israel and dedicated to Israel’s “obliteration,” seized control of Gaza after Israel’s withdrawal in 2005. It has thousands of rockets aimed at Israeli towns and farms, is smuggling in higher-grade weapons, and preaching for Israel’s destruction in its mosques and media. Hamas is also trying to take over the West Bank where Fatah is weak. A unilateral declaration ignores the grave threat that Hamas and other Palestinian terrorist groups would pose to Israelis along their eastern border, which is only a few kilometers away from their demographic heartland.

·      The Palestinians’ unilateral declaration of statehood is a ploy to bypass negotiations and to avoid making the concessions that are prerequisites to peace. Palestinians must renounce terrorism, accept the Jewish state’s right to exist within secure boundaries, honor past PLO-Israel agreements, renounce claims to Israel, and negotiate mutually agreed-upon solutions for other outstanding issues.

·      Supporting the Palestinians’ unilateral declaration of statehood is a recipe for war. None of the outstanding issues would be resolved, such as refugees and Jerusalem. Instead, the Palestinians would feel empowered to continue making maximum demands, even by force of arms and terrorism as Hamas is doing. This will not lead to the peaceful coexistence sought by Israel and moderates in the region.

·      Unilateral recognition of a Palestinian state sets a dangerous precedent that undermines international diplomacy and the principles of conflict resolution. Diplomatic processes lose their value when one party can simply walk out on them and achieve its own ends without considering the basic needs of the others—and gain international recognition anyway. The South American countries set a dangerous precedent despite their hollow claims that their recognition does not contradict their commitment to negotiations.[iv]

·    Supporting the Palestinian unilateral declaration of statehood is a crushing setback for peace. The UN Security Council resolution should be vetoed, and all efforts should be directed at getting Palestinians back to the negotiating table, not supporting their brazen campaign to avoid or bypass the peace process.

 



[1]Matthew Lee and Edith Lederer, “Palestinians defy US with Security Council request,” AP Report,  Jan. 21, 2011 at http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5j8aMPQcwg_Rn1QOpIW4qoxWWvGHA?docId=97e4aa8c01574126b4108e8cbbb26382

[2]“Ecuador Becomes Fifth Latin American Country to Recognize Palestine State,” Haaretz, Dec. 25, 2010 at http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/ecuador-becomes-fifth-latin-american-country-to-recognize-palestinian-state-1.332845

[3]Council of the European Union, “Council Conclusions on the Middle East Peace Process,” Dec. 13, 2010 at http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/EN/foraff/118448.pdf

[4]Natasha Mozgovaya,”U.S. House opposes unilateral declaration of Palestinian state,” Ha’aretz, Dec. 16, 2010 at http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/u-s-house-opposes-unilateral-declaration-of-palestinian-state-1.330922

[5]Matthew Lee and Edith Lederer, “Palestinians defy US with Security Council request,” AP Report,  Jan. 21, 2011 at http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5j8aMPQcwg_Rn1QOpIW4qoxWWvGHA?docId=97e4aa8c01574126b4108e8cbbb26382

Other stories
6/23/2017
During the last couple of weeks, Jewish and Israeli media outlets were filled with woeful ...
6/23/2017
On June 7, the Embassy of Israel in Washington D.C. commemorated the 50th anniversary of t...
6/23/2017
Did you know... ...
6/22/2017
With only about 40% of US Jews visiting Israel, more and more young adults find their Jewi...
6/21/2017
StandWithUs commends the Westchester, New York Board of Legislators for overwhelmingly (16...
6/16/2017
British-born Kay Wilson reflects on the double standards when it comes to tackling Islamis...
6/14/2017
I was riding my bike one summer evening alongside the beautiful, crashing waves and the go...
6/12/2017
StandWithUs is honored to have been selected as a finalist for the 2017 Classy.org Awards,...
6/12/2017
That`s when the 24-year-old social work student stopped by Bain`s office to tell her she`d...
6/12/2017
As Israeli actress Gal Gadot`s “Wonder Woman” film heads toward $400 million i...
6/9/2017
On Wednesday, June 7th, 2017, the Embassy of Israel in Washington D.C. commemorated the 50...
6/9/2017
In “ An Israeli-Arab`s Journey to Israel Advocacy”, we had the privilege to he...
6/9/2017
United States Ambassador to the United Nations, Nikki Haley, received a petition with thou...
6/9/2017
On Wednesday, June 7th, 2017, the Embassy of Israel in Washington D.C. commemorated the 50...
6/5/2017
While Conservative Party leader Andrew Scheer`s plan to withhold federal funding from univ...
6/5/2017
The people of London are facing the beginning of a slippery slope, one where we all know h...
6/5/2017
JERUSALEM - Israelis are celebrating 50 years since the Six-Day War - and with good reason...
6/5/2017
To the members of IfNotNow who chose to stage a disruption at Bret Stephens talk at Emanu-...
6/2/2017
New faces at StandWithUs MI...
6/2/2017
In a recent statement on the Ryerson University website, president Mohamed Lachemi emphasi...

 

About Us
Get Involved
Resources
Shop For Israel
Social Media
StandWithUs Websites