Donate Shop Register Volunteer


Dershowitz Strikes Back

DERSHOWITZ STRIKES BACK


StandWithUs was a major sponsor of this event

with Alan Dershowitz and UPenn on February 2, 2012


JEWISH EXPONENT
By, Bryan Schwartzman
February 03, 2012 

A day before the National Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions Conference was set to begin at the University of Pennsylvania, Harvard University law professor Alan Dershowitz called Penn the "model campus" when it comes to pro-Israel activism.

"You guys have stood strong, you have stood hard. You don't just let anti-Israel people get away with silence," said the 73-year-old Dershowitz, a noted lawyer, author and prominent defender of Israel in academia and the public sphere.

Later, he spoke to about 900 people at Penn's Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts. Hillel had organized an "Invest in Israel" party following the Dershowitz speech and had also planned about 80 Shabbat meals across the campus where more than 800 students were expected to take part in informal conversations about the Jewish state.On Thursday night, Feb. 2, the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia, Hillel and a host of other Jewish groups sponsored an evening with Dershowitz. The goal was to galvanize pro-Israel students in light of the expected anti-Israel message of the BDS conference. During a dinner at Hillel, Dershowitz addressed about 50 student leaders -- including a few from Drexel and Temple universities -- and about 50 Federation donors.

At the same time, pro-Israel students worked on circulating a petition blasting the conference, and Jewish groups from all the other Ivy League schools submitted a statement opposing the conference.

Dershowitz repeatedly told the students that Penn president Amy Gutmann has been handling the controversy in an exemplary manner. She has upheld the principle of freedom of expression while stating emphatically that the university values its relationship with Israel and does not support the goals of the BDS movement.

"I don't think Penn should have banned a conference. I think it is wrong for a university to be in the business of banning," Dershowitz said during the leadership dinner. "You should have a single standard. Universities should be open places, and the BDS conference gives us an opportunity to respond to hate with positive messages."

Later, at the Annenberg program, David L. Cohen, a trustee of both Penn and Federation, spoke on behalf of Gutmann. Referring to the hundreds in attendance, the Comcast vice president said that "what we are seeing here tonight is the ultimate victory of open expression."

In a brief interview, Dershowitz rejected the notion that staging large communal events brings more attention to the BDS conference than it might otherwise have gotten. He said the true agenda of the movement must be exposed.

"Their definition of occupation is Haifa and Tel Aviv. Their motto is Palestine will be free from the river to the sea," he said in the interview. "The occupation for them is a pretext."

Why are so many Jews drawn to the BDS movement?

"Jews voted for Mussolini, Jews supported Stalin," replied Dershowitz. "Don't ask me to explain Jews. You will find a Jew on every side of every issue. The number of Jews that support the movement is small. What I am more concerned about is the number of Jews that don't condemn it."

During the Annenberg program, Dershowitz put forth the liberal defense of Israel that he'd already laid out in his 2003 book The Case for Israel. He's pro-Israel, he said, because he's pro-human rights, pro-women's rights and pro-gay rights. But he did emphasize that one can be pro-Israel and disagree with some of the Jewish state's policies. For instance, Dershowitz opposes the continued building of settlements on the West Bank.

The Annenberg program took a brief detour into current presidential politics when Dershowitz said that Israel should remain a bipartisan issue. Still, the lifelong Democrat said he had backed President Barack Obama in 2008 but was critical of some of his decisions regarding Israel. He added that he hadn't decided yet whom he would vote for this year.

Regarding the possibility that Israel may launch a military strike against Iranian nuclear facilities, Dershowitz said the Jewish state is well within its rights to move ahead.

"It won't be a pre-emptive attack, it will be a reactive attack. Israel is entitled to attack Iran legally because Iran has attacked Israel illegally through arming Hezbollah and Hamas," he said.

During the question-and-answer session after the Annenberg presentation, one female student asked, "If an Arab student comes up to me and says, 'You took my land,' and I respond, 'Yeah, but we support gay rights,' how does that add up?"

Dershowitz said the answer is that the Jews didn't steal the land.

"The land on which Israel was established had a Jewish majority," he said. "In Israel's case, they bought the land, in this case from distant land owners, who lived in Syria and Lebanon. The Israeli policy of the yishuv was never to throw indigenous Arabs off the land.

"Israel's birth certificate is cleaner than the birth certificate of almost any other modern country in the world," he added. "Israel was established by law."

A number of students interviewed on campus expressed a range of emotions.* On the one hand, many said they were charged and inspired by the burst of pro-Israel activism. On the other, some said that dealing with the BDS conference had clearly taken a toll on them and the mood on campus.

Penn sophomore Lisa Felber said that the BDS conference "feels like a personal attack."

Josh Cooper, also a sophomore, said during a speech at the student leadership dinner that "this is not the most calm of moments. Things are pretty tempestuous right now. There is a lot of emotion."

Alon Krifchner, a freshman member of the Penn Israel Public Affairs Committee, said the BDS conference "has pretty much taken over our lives in the past few months, but in a good way. We see this really as a gift. We have taken this opportunity and ,we think, have drawn Israel into the forefront."

READ ARTICLE HERE

Other stories
5/26/2015
StandWithUs applauds UC President Janet Napolitano`s support for officially adopting the U...
5/26/2015
SWU-Israel director Michael Dickson was honored to be chosen to join a forum of Israeli fo...
5/26/2015
Kay Wilson, a survivor of a terror attack in Israel, will be the guest speaker at the sec...
5/26/2015
As the new government gets started, the main actors in the Mideast diplomatic drama are al...
5/26/2015
Israel has faced existential danger since its founding. It pushed back conventional assaul...
5/26/2015
StandWithUs` rolled through Oklahoma, northern Miami and North Carolina with four Israel D...
5/22/2015
Liana Kadisha, a senior at Stanford University, says some Jewish students on her campus fe...
5/22/2015
Both supporters and opponents of boycotting Israel say the other side is spewing lies. Tha...
5/21/2015
BBYO Teen Interviews StandWithUs High School Coordinators, Sarah Gipoor and Tahli Hanuka, ...
5/21/2015
Lital and Elad who participated in StandWithUs` 6th Israeli Soldiers Tour are interviewed ...
5/21/2015
PRIOR TO the official launch of the new StandWithUs headquarters off Jerusalem`s King Davi...
5/20/2015
March of the Living Holocaust educational trip to Poland and Israel makes impact on Boca R...
5/20/2015
A day after landmark legislation passes Illinois legislature, pro-Israel activists say win...
5/19/2015
StandWithUs congratulates the Illinois House which on May 18, 2015 joined the state`s sena...
5/19/2015
Illinois on Monday became the third state in a month to pass legislation formally opposing...
5/15/2015
Lital and I participated in the 6th "Israeli Soldiers Tour," speaking on campuses, high sc...
5/14/2015
Coop legal counsel finds national origin boycott could violate NY Human Rights Law....
5/14/2015
Illinois is the first state to pass legislation (SB 1761, Amendment 3) prohibiting a state...
5/13/2015
Two Israel Defense Forces (IDF) soldiers shared their personal experiences with area high...
5/13/2015
How we can begin the end of radical Islam...

 

About Us
Get Involved
Resources
Shop For Israel
Social Media
StandWithUs Websites