Donate Shop Register


'Irvine 11' Muslim students appeal conviction in free speech case
The LA Times reported on January 25 that
the Muslim students are appealing their case.

Watch this video which has been shortened to under 3 minutes, showing what they did and why they
were convicted. We just loaded it up.





'Irvine 11' Muslim students appeal conviction in free speech case



The LA Times Blogs
January 25, 2013


Ten of the so-called Irvine 11 Muslim students convicted of two misdemeanor charges to conspire and then disrupt a 2010 speech by Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren at UC Irvine have filed an appeal in Orange County Superior Court.

The 10 defendants, Muslim UC Irvine and UC Riverside students, were convicted in 2011 and sentenced to three years of informal probation and 56 hours of community service.
Charges against an 11th student were dropped after he agreed to 40 hours of community service at Someone Cares Soup Kitchen in Costa Mesa.

The case sparked fierce debate over whether the students' or Oren's free speech rights were violated, and whether the district attorney's office should have filed criminal charges in the first place.

In an appeal brief filed this week, attorneys alleged that the students were convicted on the basis of an "unconstitutionally vague" state law prohibiting the willful disturbance of meetings, the Daily Pilot reported.

"The basic premise is that this statute, as applied, makes completely lawful political speech a criminal act, and the 1st Amendment was never intended to allow that," said Dan Stormer, one of several lawyers representing the group.

Though a 1970 California Supreme Court decision "tried to fix the statute" by giving it more specific limits, the jury's instructions on how to apply the statute in question were still fuzzy, said Lisa Jaskol, directing attorney of the Public Counsel Law Center's appellate law program.

But Assistant Dist. Atty. Dan Wagner, a prosecutor working on the case, said that because the California Supreme Court had already ruled on the constitutionality of the statute, he's confident the conviction will be upheld.

"Furthermore, their behavior is not the type of behavior or conduct that is protected by the 1st Amendment," he added. "The evidence showed they were intent on taking away the ambassador's right to free speech."

Prosecutors have at least a month to file a response.

The students have completed their community service, Stormer said, and are "all doing very well."

"These young people are the cream of our academic crop," he said. "The idea that you could stand up in a meeting and make a political statement and that is a crime is absolutely abhorrent to our justice system."

Read Article Here
Other stories
12/8/2016
NEW YORK, N.Y. Hamden native Eliza Kanner, a student at the University of Connecticut, is...
12/8/2016
On Nov 22, 2016, Sarah Ruiz-Grossman, an Associate Editor at the Huffington Post, publishe...
12/2/2016
StandWithUs Canada Applauds Ontario Legislature Vote Against Intolerance on December 1, 20...
12/1/2016
I write this in fear of what we have become and accepted as our norms. I write this refle...
12/1/2016
The boycott, divestment and sanctions movement has various offshoots worldwide. To educate...
11/30/2016
StandWithUs is partnering with North West Friends of Israel and Sussex Friends of Israel f...
11/30/2016
Over the past year and a half, I found myself disappointed by the relentless hatred that h...
11/29/2016
On Tuesday, November 8th, the United States witnessed an unprecedented election. After ext...
11/28/2016
Leaders of Tomorrow Gala was held at Gotham in Manhattan, NY on November 13th, 2016 by Sta...
11/28/2016
Rayna Exelbierd, StandWithUs Southeast High School Coordinator will share her journey fro...
11/25/2016
Midreshet Shalhevet`s Committee for Israel Activism (CIA), led by Mr. Simcha Bader and clu...
11/23/2016
The first time Israeli animal rights activist Chen Cohen met the StandWithUs staffer who i...
11/23/2016
Like any teen, Muhammad Zoabi dreamed he might make his mark someday. He did, but not in t...
11/17/2016
StandWithUs Espanol...
11/16/2016
StandWithUs Congratulates U of Michigan Students for Defeating Discriminatory Divestment R...
11/16/2016
Alums for Campus Fairness congratulates Oberlin College...
11/15/2016
Wrapped in Israeli flags and holding signs condemning UNESCO, hundreds of people walked in...
11/15/2016
On this unseasonably warm and sunny day, students sit on the grassy knoll of McGill Univer...
11/15/2016
Around this time a year ago, the Daily, as well as many other publications throughout the ...

 

About Us
Get Involved
Resources
Shop For Israel
Social Media
StandWithUs Websites