Only Available for California Residents-18 Years or Older
Donate Shop Register Volunteer


Clear moral lines: barring BDS from Hillel
Clear moral lines: barring BDS from Hillel


Sara Greenberg
Times of Israel
February 26, 2013


When demonstrators in Antwerp chant Hamas, Hamas, all Jews to the gas and when Jewish children are shot and killed in Toulouse in front of a Jewish school, most of the world recognizes these acts as anti-Semitism.

Unfortunately, it is the more subtle, nuanced manifestations of racism and anti-Semitism that often get overlooked. Natan Sharansky wrote in a 2004 essay, Seeing Anti-Semitism in 3D, that:

    "whereas classical anti-Semitism was seen as being aimed at the Jewish religion or the Jewish people, the new anti-Semitism is ostensibly directed against the Jewish State. Since this anti-Semitism can hide behind the veneer of the legitimate criticism of Israel, it is much more difficult to expose."

A group of Harvard students recently launched a campaign protesting a local and international Hillel policy that bans partnerships with student groups that support boycott of, divestment from, or sanctions against the State of Israel. In an open letter to the Hillel community, the Harvard College Progressive Jewish Alliance (PJA), lamented the fact that it was unable to hold an event at the Harvard Hillel co-sponsored by the Harvard College Palestine Solidarity Committee, a group that wholly endorses the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement (BDS) against Israel. The PJA, upset by this decision, launched a campaign demanding Hillel have no policy on the political affiliation of groups, organizations and speakers that it partners with, houses, and hosts.

The PJA leaves room for one exception. In my conversation with the groups leaders last week they acknowledge that while Hillel should foster open discussion, critical thinking and debate this, of course, does not mean that Hillel needs to provide space for the expression of racist, anti-Semitic, or otherwise hateful views. The PJA understands that while a student group can engage in a dialogue with any person or group it chooses even if this speaker or group espouses hateful views a University, a University Department or a campus organization like Hillel cannot be compelled and has the right to refuse to underwrite, sponsor or endorse any speaker or event.

Is BDS any different than other hate groups that seek to deny rights to groups of people based on ethnicity, race, religion or sexuality? Would anyone argue that the Harvard African and African American studies department be required to sponsor a member of the Ku Klux Klan to speak on campus?

BDS advocates for a global campaign to boycott, divest from and sanction the State of Israel until it complies with its obligation under international and human rights law. BDS leaders claim and many followers believe that the movement promotes freedom, equal rights,and world peace, with a focus on the basic rights of the Palestinian people. Given these statements, you would expect BDS to call for sanctions against Syria, where nearly 1000 Palestinians have been killed in the past year, or to boycott Gaza, where under the authority of Hamas, political and religious freedom is curtailed and womens rights are severely limited. Yet BDS has remained silent on these issues. Instead, the movement focuses on Israel, the one nation in the Middle East that affords full rights to women and minorities.

So what are the obligations that BDS would require Israel to meet under international law? According to the BDS website, Israel must respect, protect and promote the rights of Palestinian refugees to return to [Israel]. But not only does the Right of Return have no basis in law or appear in any UN resolutions, President Barack Obama also pointed out in 2008 that the Right of Returnwould extinguish Israel as a Jewish State. Omar Barghouti, a key leader of BDS, understands this: If the [Palestinian] refugees were to return, you would not have a two state solution, youd have a Palestine next to a Palestine, he told students at Yale University earlier this month at an event sponsored by Yale Students for Justice in Palestine.

By promoting the right of Palestinian refugees to return to Israel, BDS knowingly advocates, however inconspicuously, for the annihilation of Israel as a Jewish state. Denying the Jewish people a state, while endorsing the creation of a new ethnic nation state such as Palestine, is anti-Semitic. As Abe Foxman, the National Director of the Anti-Defamation League wrote on February 8th in an open letter in The New York Times: we are talking here about hate, not mere criticism. The BDS movement at its very core is anti-Semitic.

Many BDS supporters and sympathizers, including students at Harvard, may not understand the movements true goals. But once you realize that BDS promotes hate, not peace, you also realize that engaging with BDS is antithetical to creating an environment where meaningful, peaceful and constructive dialogue can take place.

Anti-Semitism can only be defeated if it is exposed. Harvard Hillel, under the international Hillel umbrella, is correct to establish clear moral guidelines that prohibit partnerships with or sponsorship of groups, Jewish and non-Jewish, that deny the right of Israel to exist. Evil cannot be defeated if it cannot be recognized, wrote Sharansky in 2004, and the only way to recognize evil is to draw clear moral lines.


Read article here
Other stories
4/24/2014
On March 19, the Council of the Royal Institute of British Architects [RIBA] voted to call...
4/24/2014
If a small group of grassroots Jewish organizations have their way, more than one hundred ...
4/24/2014
Earth Day Giveaways....
4/24/2014
The Cabinet today (Thursday, 24 April), unanimously decided that Israel will not negotiate...
4/24/2014
StandWithUs congratulates UCSB students, along with Rabbi Evan Goodman and the staff at Sa...
4/24/2014
Resolutions to divest from Israel were resoundingly defeated in votes by the student gover...
4/23/2014
This is the ninth in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time in s...
4/23/2014
This is the tenth in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time in s...
4/23/2014
This is the eleventh in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time i...
4/23/2014
Sharon, 26, described the day when she had to send a signal to her hometown, Haifa, lettin...
4/23/2014
Dueling advertisements for and against American tax dollars being given to Israel and the ...
4/23/2014
There is a scene in Guys and Dolls, the Damon Runyan-inspired tale about entertaining mobs...
4/23/2014
A Palestinian Authority [PA] minister who equated Jewish blood with Palestinian blood has ...
4/23/2014
One of the libels continuously repeated by the PA is that Israel is planning to destroy th...
4/18/2014
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict played out on Metrobuses in Washington during the annual ...
4/17/2014
In the mailboxes of the average American 17-year-old, one might find birthday cards from r...
4/17/2014
This is the eighth in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time in ...
4/14/2014
The Boycott, Divest and Sanction movement against Israel is often seen as progressive — ...
4/14/2014
Professor Mohammed S. Dajani took 27 Palestinian college students to visit the Auschwitz c...
4/14/2014
Yishai and Ilana are students at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, but they weren`t visi...

 

About Us
Get Involved
Resources
Shop For Israel
Social Media
StandWithUs Websites