Only Available for California Residents-18 Years or Older
Donate Shop Register Volunteer


How visits from an Iranian-Israeli musician and Iraqi-Jewish-American writer to
How visits from an Iranian-Israeli musician and Iraqi-Jewish-American writer to Stanford demonstrate that divestment is faulty



By Doniel Kaye
The Stanford Daily
March 5, 2013


On November 3rd, Stanford hosted Iranian-Israeli musician Rita Jahanforuz.  The 50-year-old celebrity has delighted audiences in Israel for decades with her unique blending of music genres from throughout the Middle East.  She espouses her intent to puncture the wall of tension between Israel and Iran, hoping to bridge divides between people through her multicultural personal background and musical medleys.  As she puts it, her aim is to serve as an ambassador of peace.  Melodious in both her ability to harmonize music and unite people of various backgrounds, Rita is the quintessential multicultural success story.

Earlier this month, the author and radio show host Joseph Braude addressed the ways in which different ethnic and cultural demographics within Israel produces the multiculturalism Jahanforuz celebrates through her music.  Mr. Braude was invited to speak at Stanford on the topic of Jews in the Arab World from the perspective of a seasoned reporter and an Iraqi Jewish-American.  Braudes talk, which was sponsored by JIMENA (Jews Indigenous to the Middle East and North Africa), highlighted the little-known story of Jewish refugees from Arab countries.

Mr. Braude expressed how grave circumstances led to the migration of Arab Jews from Arab lands after the Israeli War of Independence in 1948.  Approximately 850,000 Jews were expelled or forced to flee from the Middle East and North Africa.

Just two significant Jewish communities remain in North Africa, in Morocco and Tunisia.  The once robust community of a quarter million Jews in Morocco is now 6,000.  The Tunisian Jewish population of 100,000 has dwindled to 2,000.

Many of these displaced persons immigrated to Israel. Largely as a result, nearly half of the Israeli population is of Middle Eastern and North African descent, accounting for much of the nations diverse ethnic and cultural composition.

Approximately 20% of the Israeli population is non-Jewish, and 14% identify as Arab-Muslim.  All citizens, regardless of race or creed, are represented and participate fully in Israeli national politics.  Arab-Muslims have held as many as 12 of the 120 seats in the Israeli parliament, or Knesset, and add significantly to the plurality of opinions and perspectives represented in Israeli society.

As Stanford students interested in gaining more comprehensive, nuanced, and accurate understandings of current developments around the world, including the Arab-Israeli conflict, it is imperative to familiarize ourselves with these stories the stories of Jews from Arab countries as well as other minorities who have been affected by tension and intolerance.  Understanding the origins of current demographic realities in the region will help us to more fully contextualize different narratives on crucial issues affecting Israel notably among them divestment, which is currently under debate in the ASSU Undergraduate Senate.

The Associated Students of Stanford University are responsible for representing the entire student body, and by extension, exercise discretion and sensibility when considering proposals that will affect the university.  The Selective Divestment campaign is connected to the international Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement, which aims to undermine reconciliation efforts between the Palestinians and Israelis by singling out Israel as the antagonist in the conflict through a process of targeted demonization.

Much like the United States, Israel is and always has been a melting pot, a nation composed of peoples of myriad ethnic and cultural backgrounds.  Yes, Israel is imperfect no one will deny this.

But let us look at the bigger picture.  How does Israel approach its problems?  It does so rigorously, through multicultural democratic processes through public debate, discourse and compromise.  The scale is in constant flux.  The balancing act never ends.  Just as any other society striving toward the ideal of democracy, Israel is working on striking the right balance, to preserve both liberty and security.

Targeting a country populated by peoples of various backgrounds a country that pursues and strives for justice, congruity, and equality in all facets of public life is unwise and counterproductive.  When the international community condemns Israel, like the BDS campaign does without question, it serves to alienate rather than unite.  Perversely but understandably, it makes Israel feel more weary of a world that insists on criticizing and vilifying its actions rather than collaborating in efforts toward peace.

If the ASSU chooses to support BDS, indubitably, many students will be estranged.  Many will be extremely offended, uncomfortable, and unaccepted.  At a minimum, the ASSU, as a deliberative body representing all the students at Stanford, must understand the consequences of its actions.

Doniel Kaye
Stanford University Class of 2015
StandWithUs Emerson Fellow
Campus Outreach Chair of the Stanford Israel Alliance



Read article here
Other stories
4/24/2014
On March 19, the Council of the Royal Institute of British Architects [RIBA] voted to call...
4/24/2014
If a small group of grassroots Jewish organizations have their way, more than one hundred ...
4/24/2014
Earth Day Giveaways....
4/24/2014
The Cabinet today (Thursday, 24 April), unanimously decided that Israel will not negotiate...
4/24/2014
StandWithUs congratulates UCSB students, along with Rabbi Evan Goodman and the staff at Sa...
4/24/2014
Resolutions to divest from Israel were resoundingly defeated in votes by the student gover...
4/23/2014
This is the ninth in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time in s...
4/23/2014
This is the tenth in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time in s...
4/23/2014
This is the eleventh in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time i...
4/23/2014
Sharon, 26, described the day when she had to send a signal to her hometown, Haifa, lettin...
4/23/2014
Dueling advertisements for and against American tax dollars being given to Israel and the ...
4/23/2014
There is a scene in Guys and Dolls, the Damon Runyan-inspired tale about entertaining mobs...
4/23/2014
A Palestinian Authority [PA] minister who equated Jewish blood with Palestinian blood has ...
4/23/2014
One of the libels continuously repeated by the PA is that Israel is planning to destroy th...
4/18/2014
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict played out on Metrobuses in Washington during the annual ...
4/17/2014
In the mailboxes of the average American 17-year-old, one might find birthday cards from r...
4/17/2014
This is the eighth in a series of stories told by former IDF soldiers about their time in ...
4/14/2014
The Boycott, Divest and Sanction movement against Israel is often seen as progressive — ...
4/14/2014
Professor Mohammed S. Dajani took 27 Palestinian college students to visit the Auschwitz c...
4/14/2014
Yishai and Ilana are students at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, but they weren`t visi...

 

About Us
Get Involved
Resources
Shop For Israel
Social Media
StandWithUs Websites